I was going to write about the new anime series for the new season that starts this month, but then I came upon this post by a fellow wordpress.com blogger JP Meyer on the buzz/hype that surrounds one of this season’s new series, The Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi (涼宮ハルヒの憂鬱). He made some good points in his post and I think I’ll put in my cents as well. As for this season’s other new series, I’ll leave it to another post.
I’ll start off by saying that I’m in the “I just don’t get it” camp. For the 3 episodes that I have watched so far, I don’t see anything so special that justifies the buzz I’ve seen. The story isn’t particularly interesting. Episode 1 is just showing that amateur movie they made. There is some humor here and there, but overall it’s only mildly funny. If there were parodies of any kind, I didn’t see it nor get it. The first half of episodes 2 is to show what kind of a wacko Haruhi is and the second half and episode 3 are about how Haruhi bullies people into submission as she tries to get her SOS-dan going. A lot of the stuff isn’t funny, especially the scene where Haruhi blackmailed the computer club into letting her taking one of their computers. If there was anything that I found funny, it has to be the witty comments by Kyon. The comments he makes throughout these episodes are pretty funny and they make watching that loose cannon that is Haruhi tolerable. Storywise, at least for only 3 episodes, I’m simply not impressed.
There’s also this whole thing about the dance in the ED. I agree with JP (who actually likes the show a lot) that I don’t see why this is particularly good, as there are a number of shows that have their characters dance during OP/ED. The dance itself is very well animated, but it has more to do with the amazing job that Kyoto Animation has done. The fact that it is well animated doesn’t make the dance itself any “cuter” or “cooler” than the others I have seen. I think the ED is nice, and quite a bit better than some of the lazy crap (eg. Mai-Otome and Ergo Proxy) that I have seen lately. It’s just that I don’t think it’s as AWESOME as some people make it out to be.
The Dance During ED
Is there anything good to say about this show? Sure of course. The animation is top-notch, as expected from Kyoto Animation. The backgrounds look pretty and a lot of attention has be paid to the characters’ (more like only Haruhi’s) idiosyncrasies such as the way they walk. (In the OP Haruhi walks in a slightly different way.) The art is also very consistent that unlike some other shows where by episode 3 or 4 one would notice the way the characters are drawn doesn’t look the same anymore and the sloppiness shows. And as I said earlier, although I find a lot of the stuff not very funny, I really like Kyon’s witty comments. Sugita Tomokazu (杉田智和), the voice behind Kyon, has done a pretty good job here.
As to why the show is so popular, well, I’ll throw a few wild guesses out here, and see which ones stick:
- The first episode starts off in such an odd way that it gives viewers the impression that may be this is something different. Something so different from other shows that it has to be great.
- “Moe” factor: Haruhi, Mikuru, Yuki, bouncing breasts, glasses, and bunny suits.
- The show is funny. Laugh. Damn it.
- Superior art and animation.
- The Dance.
- Cute aliens? (Check out the end of episode 3.)
- Because other people say so.
Overall I personally find this show to be average. There are a number of new shows for this season that I enjoy watching more than Haruhi. I think I’m going to watch a couple of more episodes to see if the story would pick up a bit. As it is I think I would watch other shows instead.